Skip to main content

RULE OF THUMB FOR CALCULATING DISTRIBUTION FEEDER LOSS

How can we estimate the distribution feeder loss using a single formula?

The distribution system of an electric utility is a very complex system that is composed of many different kinds of electrical equipment. To mention a few of these components, this would include the feeder lines or wires which in reality are of different size and lengths, distribution transformers of different kVa rating capacity, low voltage lines, etc. 
Traditionally, in computing for the total distribution feeder loss, one would manually compute for the individual line loss of every section in the distribution system considering the actual length and actual loading of that section. In the advent for computer technology, this computation became more readily available through computer simulation using numerical methods and analysis.
However, if one electrical engineer wishes to compute for the feeder loss of a certain distribution system, he would either manually compute for it or purchase a very expensive application that is capable of simulating this value. The former would be highly time impractical and the latter to be financially impractical especially for an electric utility which are low income generating.
IEEE, 1994-1997 published a simplified method in computing or estimating the total loss of a certain distribution system. This simple formula is called Chen Simplified Feeder Loss. This formula was derived from using regression analysis of study involving load flow simulations. The formula is composed of four variables; total primary conductor length (km), secondary conductor length (km), total transformer capacity (MVA), feeder loading (MW), and power factor of feeder loading.
Refer to the formula below to understand how we can derive with an estimate for the distribution feeder loss using only this basic distribution systems information.

feeder loss formula

Comparison example between the Chen formula and the result of Synergee feeder loss simulation:

Ploss: 32.6433+0.752PLH+2.0041SLH -0.0908TR^2+3.0206(LD/PF)^2
A certain feeder having the parameters specified below needs to evaluated on the estimate of its feeder loss.
PLH: 10.3 (km)
SLH: 106.4 (km)
TR: 8.2135 (MVA)
LD: 4.214 (MW)
PF: 99%
Substituting the above parameter to the Chen formula would result to 247.5051 kw of feeder loss or approximately 5.87%. The same feeder if simulated using Synergee software has a total percent feeder loss of 5.99% 
Labels:

Comments

  1. UnknownNovember 27, 2013 at 10:29 AM

    The correct answer to the sample problem based on the given values should be 302.2279kW instead of 247.5051kW. Please verify. thanks

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

PARTS OF A POWER TRANSFORMER

What are the name of the basic parts of a Power Transformer? We can not deny the fact that only a handful of electrical engineering students are presently familiar with power transformers especially on what it looks like. Unlike a transformer we found in our homes, a power transformer’s appearance and construction is somewhat more complicated. It is not just a simple winding with a primary and secondary terminal although basically any transformer has one. The function that a power transformer plays in an electrical system is very important that an electric utility can not afford to loss it during its operation. Our discussion here will focus more on the basic parts and functions of a power transformer that are usually tangible whenever you go to a substation . Although not all power transformers are identical, nonetheless they all have the following listed parts in which the way of construction may differ.
50 comments
click here to continue

ELECTRIC MOTOR FRAME SIZE STANDARD SPECIFICATIONS

ELECTRIC MOTOR FRAME SIZE STANDARD SPECIFICATIONS How is electric motor frame size being specified? Motor frame dimensions have been standardized with a uniform frame size numbering system. This system was developed by NEMA and specific frame sizes have been assigned to standard motor ratings based on enclosure, horsepower and speed. The current standardized frames for integral horsepower induction motors ranges from 143T to 445T. These standards cover most motors in the range of one through two hundred horsepower. Typical example of where you can locate the frame is shown in Fig 1.2.D – Frame No. The numbers used to designate frame sizes have specific meanings based on the physical size of the motor. Some digits are related to the motor shaft height and the remaining digit or digits relate to the length of the motor. The rerate, or frame size reduction programs were brought about by advancements in motor technology relating mainly to higher temperature ratings of insulating mate...
5 comments
click here to continue

ELECTRIC MOTOR NAMEPLATE SPECIFICATIONS

How do we interpret an electric motor nameplate? Motor standards are established on a country by country basis.Fortunately though, the standards can be grouped into two major categories: NEMA and IEC (and its derivatives). In North America, the National Electric Manufacturers Association (NEMA) sets motor standards, including what should go on the nameplate (NEMA Standard MG 1-10.40 "Nameplate Marking for Medium Single-Phase and Polyphase Induction Motors").
43 comments
click here to continue